Jun28

absence.

Posted on by
Standard
An empty classroom in Italy
A teacher in Italy who was sacked for 20 years of absence in 24 years at schools near Venice has vowed to tell her side of the story. 

Cinzia Paolina De Lio was dismissed in 2017 after she reappeared for four months and triggered complaints.

Italy’s highest court confirmed the dismissal after a legal battle, saying her absences showed a “permanent and absolute ineptitude”. Ms De Lio has condemned the ruling and vowed to “reconstruct the truth”.

The secondary school teacher, who specialises in history and philosophy, said she had documents to prove her story but told Repubblica newspaper: “Sorry, but right now I’m at the beach.”

“I will reconstruct the truth of the facts of this absolutely unique and surreal story”, she said adding, “I don’t answer questions from journalists thrown around that wouldn’t do justice to the truth of my story.”

Ms De Lio was reinstated in 2018 after a ruling by a judge in Venice but the education ministry appealed against the decision and it was reversed by the Supreme Court of Cassation last week.

The ministry argued that the teacher had kept out of the classroom for 20 out of her 24 years of service. For the first 10 years she was completely absent, and her absences in the other 14 years were attributed to sickness, personal or family reasons.

The court heard that in a four-month period in 2015 when she did teach in Chioggia near Venice, students complained of her lack of preparedness, her failure to bring textbooks and her “random and improvised” way of marking. An inspection found she was “unprepared” and “inattentive”, and students refused to take part in her classes as she was distracted by her phone.

Her 2017 dismissal turned into a legal battle, going through an appeal and counter-appeal, before finally arriving at the top court. Her defence of “freedom of teaching” was rejected by the court which argued it was the teacher’s responsibility to guarantee students’ right to study.

Describing herself now as a freelance journalist, she told Italian media that she had documents to refute the claim that she had been absent for 20 years. The education ministry said it would “increasingly strive to ensure that the activity of teaching is carried out with adequate professionalism”.
—
“absence is presence with distance.”
-taeyoon choi
—-
Credits: Story – Mattea Bubalo, BBC News, Image – Getty Images

 

Discover more from I didn't have my glasses on....

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

61 responses »

  7. Bizzaro! Her colleagues obviously preferred her to be absent rather than present. The students, likely relieved at not having to put up with her. And the state continued to pay her salary. As she says … Such a surreal situation.

    Liked by 1 person

    Reply ↓

  11. Oh man…or woman in this case. :) And I’m pretty sure she got paid all those years whether she was there or not. That’s crazy! I’m dying to hear what her reasons for the absences were..but how could she remember 20 years worth of them? Hah!

    Liked by 1 person

    Reply ↓

  21. These are rare situations as most teachers are incredibly dedicated. Unfortunately, it’s the last thing the profession needs as some anti-education/anti-teacher union will try to portray this as the norm. We need to weed out the bad ones like this that bring shame to the profession. I feel the same way about law enforcement. The majority are great and do a difficult job well, but some behaviors are indefensible and those are the ones we need to rid.

    Liked by 1 person

    Reply ↓

  27. I simply fail to grasp how this could go unnoticed for SO many years. And the audacity of that woman to exclaim that the story wasn’t true! I also think that happenings like this is so NOT what our teachers need. They invest so much of themselves to give kids a happy childhood, a good education – and then comes along one of the ‘Cinzias’…

    Like

    Reply ↓

Leave a reply to SusanR Cancel reply